Skip to main content

Saucy Salads and Sandwiches at the Edgewater Beach Hotel

 The grounds of the Edgewater Beach Hotel. Postcard published by Curt Teich Co., Chicago. 
Seeing the pink high-rise Edgewater Beach Apartments on Sheridan Road near Bryn Mawr Avenue makes one think of the famed Edgewater Beach Hotel structures that once stood nearby.

In its heyday in the 1920s through the 1940s, the hotel was a popular spot with honeymooners and visiting celebrities alike. You could also eat one heck of a salad or sandwich there.

Arnold Shircliffe, who worked as the catering manager at the hotel, wrote A Book of Salads in 1926 and The Edgewater Sandwich Book in 1930. A sampling of recipes from these cookbooks shows that Shircliffe knew how to elevate these everyday convenience foods into works of art. He also had very different ideas about salads and sandwiches than what we typically eat today.

The Colonnade Room at the Edgewater Beach Hotel. Postcard published by Max Rigot Selling Agency of Chicago. 

A Book of Salads was referred to as “the bible of salad makers” according to the Chicago Tribune archives. In this book, Shircliffe lays out the 5 basic types of salad dressing: French dressing, mayonnaise, animal fat, sour cream, and “cooked dressing.” Cheese was a key ingredient in many of his salads, and presentation was key. For example, the Iron Salad consisted of dates, raisins, cottage cheese, endive, and cress artfully arranged on a plate. And although the Tribune states that Shircliffe was “exceedingly fond of lettuce,” this key ingredient seemed to be used mainly for decorative purposes. Shircliffe’s Breakfast Salad recipe begins with a measly 2 or 3 lettuce leaves, on top of which is piled tomato, scrambled eggs whipped with cream and Worcestershire sauce, and boiled ham.

The Edgewater Sandwich Book included recipes for a Pig’s Feet Sandwich, a Rabbit Sandwich, and even a Squirrel Sandwich, just to name a few. Shircliffe’s Prune Sandwich consisted of prunes, lemon juice, mayonnaise, butter, and lettuce on whole-wheat bread, offering a slightly healthier option. The Cannibal Sandwich featured raw ground beef mixed with onions and seasoning as its main ingredient. “Sprinkle with chopped chives and criss-cross with fork tines to give a decorative appearance,” the recipe concludes. Shircliffe dedicated The Edgewater Sandwich Book to none other than the Earl of Sandwich, the Brit who invented the lunchtime staple.  

Marine Dining Room. Postcard published by Curt Teich & Co. of Chicago.

Shircliffe went on to become manager of the Wrigley Building restaurant, a position he held until his death in 1952 at the age of 72. Perhaps Shircliffe’s fondness for rich ingredients stemmed from his time spent serving his country prior to his time at the Edgewater Beach Hotel. During World War I, he initiated food train service for U.S. troops in France. And during World War II, he was a food consultant to the U.S. Army and Navy. One thing is for sure: After reading samples from these cookbooks, I will never think of salads and sandwiches the same way again. And one more thing: If you’re going to make a Cannibal Sandwich, it had better look decorative.

Written by Emily Ruzich

Note: Special thanks to Amy Dobrowolsky for telling me about A Book of Salads and providing the inspiration for this post.
The following blogs also provided excerpts from the cookbooks:                                                                
Cookbook of the Day ( 
A Study of Reading Habits (

A second postcard of the Marine Dining Room. This postcard was published by Max Rigot Selling Agency of Chicago.


  1. A "Cannibal Sandwich" is just steak tartar.

  2. The pink Edgewater Beach Apartments were never a hotel building; they’ve always been apartments. The two hotel buildings shown on the postcard were yellow and were torn down. This is a common mistake.

  3. Out of curiosity I made a prune sandwich, and it was better than I expected.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Going to Graceland

Graceland Cemetery is also known for its beautiful landscape and magnificent trees. Postcard printed by V.O. Hammon of Chicago. Situated at Irving Park Rd. and Clark St. near Wrigley Field is Graceland Cemetery, a scenic 119-acre burial ground and arboretum where many of Chicago’s elite have been laid to rest. The cemetery was established in 1860 by lawyer Thomas Bryan and designed by landscape architects H.W.S. Cleveland, Ossian Simonds, and William Le Baron Jenney, who is also known for designing the first skyscraper. Graceland became famous as the “Cemetery of Architects.” Along with its three designers, other prominent architects who are buried in Graceland include Louis Sullivan, who designed the Carson Pirie Scott building; Ludwig Mies van der Rohe, who designed Chicago’s Federal Center; and Fazlur Khan, who designed the Sears Tower and John Hancock Center. The grave of architect Daniel Burnham, who was chief of construction for the 1893 Columbian Exposition, lies on a small, wo

Lost Souls on Chicago's Forgotten Suicide Bridge

On this postcard, the bridge is called Suicide Bridge instead of its official name High Bridge. Postcard publication is unknown.  A tall pedestrian bridge that was built over the Lincoln Park Lagoon in 1894 was later dubbed “Suicide Bridge” after the structure became a popular place for people to take their own lives . It is believed that about 100 people jumped off of the bridge during its 25 years. Located south of Fullerton and east of Lincoln Park Zoo near Webster Avenue (originally called Asylum Place), High Bridge allowed pedestrians to cross from Lincoln Park to the lakefront. At 75 feet--or four stories--tall, the bridge was built high enough to allow sailboats to pass underneath. It was so high that people standing on the bridge on a clear day could see as far as the stockyards, Jackson Park, and the steel mills.   High Bridge was featured in a chase scene in the 1916 film Cousin Jim . The stuntman hired to jump off the bridge refused to do it because he thought

The Most Haunted Hotel in Chicago

  The Congress Hotel at 520 S. Michigan is "one of the most beautiful hotels in the middle west," according to this postcard. Published by the Aero Distributing Co., Chicago. The Congress Plaza Hotel at 520 S. Michigan Avenue is one of Chicago’s oldest and largest hotels. It was also one of the tallest buildings in Chicago for a time. With over 800 hotel rooms and so many people coming and going over the years, the Congress Plaza has seen its share of accidents, drug overdoses, murders, and suicides, earning it the distinction of being the most haunted hotel in the city. The Congress Plaza Hotel was built in 1893 to house visitors to the World’s Columbian Exhibition. In the 1920s, mobster Al Capone was known to play cards on Friday nights in a meeting room at the hotel. According to the Choose Chicago website, Capone also had a private suite on the hotel’s eighth floor. Some say that ghosts of the victims of the 1929 St. Valentine’s Day Massacre, which was believed to be or