Skip to main content

The Most Haunted Hotel in Chicago

 

The Congress Hotel at 520 S. Michigan is "one of the most beautiful hotels in the middle west," according to this postcard. Published by the Aero Distributing Co., Chicago.

The Congress Plaza Hotel at 520 S. Michigan Avenue is one of Chicago’s oldest and largest hotels. It was also one of the tallest buildings in Chicago for a time. With over 800 hotel rooms and so many people coming and going over the years, the Congress Plaza has seen its share of accidents, drug overdoses, murders, and suicides, earning it the distinction of being the most haunted hotel in the city.

The Congress Plaza Hotel was built in 1893 to house visitors to the World’s Columbian Exhibition. In the 1920s, mobster Al Capone was known to play cards on Friday nights in a meeting room at the hotel. According to the Choose Chicago website, Capone also had a private suite on the hotel’s eighth floor. Some say that ghosts of the victims of the 1929 St. Valentine’s Day Massacre, which was believed to be orchestrated by Capone, wander the halls of the hotel. Others say the ghost of Capone himself haunts the eighth floor.


A marble corridor in the hotel. Postcard published by V.O. Hammon Publishing., Chicago. 

The Congress Plaza has been the site of political rallies and presidential conventions. Eight US presidents have stayed there. In the 1930s, Benny Goodman broadcast his radio show from the hotel’s Urban Room nightclub. During World War II, the hotel was used as a military training facility. The Congress Plaza Hotel was also the site of the longest hotel labor strike in history during the years 2003 through 2013.

Serial killer H.H. Holmes—whose story was made infamous in the book The Devil in the White City--was even known to loiter in the Congress Plaza’s lobby during the 1893 World’s Fair. Holmes would allegedly lure young women who couldn’t get rooms at the hotel to stay at his South Side building instead, where many would meet an untimely end.

Author and historian Ursula Bielski has written extensively about the Congress Plaza Hotel in her Chicago Hauntings blog. According to Bielski, an elevator operator at the hotel fell seventy feet to the subfloor in 1904. In 1926, a hotel guest fell six stories down an elevator shaft. In 1939, an immigrant from Prague booked a room on the thirteenth floor of the hotel. It was there that the distressed woman threw her two young sons out of the window before jumping out herself. No one survived. The woman’s widower later described the family’s despair at being forced to flee their home and family to escape the Nazis. Legend has it that one of the young boy’s bodies never made it to the city morgue. Many guests of the hotel have reported encounters with the ghost of a young boy who makes mischief by causing lights to flicker on and off and causing guests’ room keys to go temporarily missing.


The hotel is located across the street from Grant Park. Postcard published by E.C. Kropp Co., Milwaukee.

Another ghost who is known to cause mild mayhem in the hotel has been affectionately named Peg Leg Johnny. He makes noise in the middle of the night by moving furniture and slamming doors. Guests staying on the third floor often call the front desk to complain that a one-legged vagrant has made his way into the hotel, only to have their claims proven unfounded. A former hotel operator who worked at the hotel in the 1940s remembered a resident of the hotel with a wooden leg who always wore a smile and tipped generously. The man died of a heart attack while eating breakfast at the hotel one ill-fated morning.

Bielski has even written about a room in the hotel that has allegedly been sealed up with its furnishings still intact. The door to the room has been drywalled over, but the lintel above the doorway can still be seen. No members of the hotel staff will divulge the reason why this room has been closed off, but the room’s number—666—may offer a clue.

It’s no surprise that Travel + Leisure magazine named the Congress Plaza Hotel the most haunted place in Illinois in 2016. More ghost stories about the hotel can be found in the sources listed below. Some are quite gruesome. Since the hotel was built over 125 years ago, much has changed in Chicago. But the universal experiences of fear and despair still haunt us all, both the living and the undead. 

Written by Emily Ruzich

The hotel provides many amenities, including restaurants and bars. Postcard published by Peerless Litho Co., Chicago.


More ghost stories about the Congress Plaza Hotel can be found at:

Chicago Hauntings blog: https://chicagohauntings.com

Windy City ghosts blog: https://windycityghots.com

Haunted Places podcast: The Congress Plaza Hotel episode (dated Nov. 28 2019)                          Special thank you to Sylvia Davila, who introduced me to this podcast, which inspired me to write this post.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Lost Souls on Chicago's Forgotten Suicide Bridge

On this postcard, the bridge is called Suicide Bridge instead of its official name High Bridge. Postcard publication is unknown.  A tall pedestrian bridge that was built over the Lincoln Park Lagoon in 1894 was later dubbed “Suicide Bridge” after the structure became a popular place for people to take their own lives . It is believed that about 100 people jumped off of the bridge during its 25 years. Located south of Fullerton and east of Lincoln Park Zoo near Webster Avenue (originally called Asylum Place), High Bridge allowed pedestrians to cross from Lincoln Park to the lakefront. At 75 feet--or four stories--tall, the bridge was built high enough to allow sailboats to pass underneath. It was so high that people standing on the bridge on a clear day could see as far as the stockyards, Jackson Park, and the steel mills.   High Bridge was featured in a chase scene in the 1916 film Cousin Jim . The stuntman hired to jump off the bridge refused to do it because he thought

Marshall Field's at Christmas

  The aisle on the first floor of the State Street store is 358 feet long. Postcard publisher is unknown.  Many Chicagoans continue to miss visiting Marshall Field’s during the holiday season. Just talking about the famed Christmas windows and holiday decorations brings about memories of the department store’s glory days. Many of us can recall the strong smell of perfume that would greet visitors upon entering the flagship State Street store, along with the huge white Romanesque columns decorated with Christmas fare on the first floor. The real fun, however, was taking the elevator to the 7 th floor to get a glimpse of the giant Christmas tree inside the Walnut Room restaurant. The best place to view the tree was one floor up on a balcony area. Christmas decorations on the first floor. Postcard publisher is unknown.  Frango mint chocolates were piled high in various areas throughout the store, and many visitors couldn’t resist buying a box. Frango chocolates were once made in a kitc

Putting the “Toddle” Back in “That Toddling Town”

  Postcard designed and sold by appshop. The “toddle” was a jazz dance step that became popular across the nation just in time for the Roaring Twenties. And Chicago became known as “that toddling town” thanks to the lyrics of Fred Fisher’s 1922 song “Chicago (That Toddling Town).” While many still know Frank Sinatra’s famous cover version of that song, the dance step has largely been forgotten. In a 1921 South Bend News-Times article, dance teacher Arthur Murray describes the toddle as having the “delightful abandon so characteristic of everything American.” According to Murray, the toddle was similar to the shimmy but without the shoulder shakes. It also bore a resemblance to the fox trot but with an extra bounce added to the steps. Songwriter Fred Fisher was not the first to associate the toddle with Chicago. A variation of the toddle, which focused on movements of the hips rather than the feet, was called “the Chicago toddle” or simply “the Chicago.” In 1921, a print advertiseme